The Causes of Hoarseness
Dr. Bob's Special Guest: Dr. Clifford Johnson,
ENT
|
|
Introduction
Dr. Bob: Welcome to The Dr. Bob Show. Thank you for
dropping by, trying to learn a little bit about making yourself
healthier and happier. That's what we are going to be doing.
I hope that this week you've had a good one but I hope that
you have been exercising 20 minutes seven days a week. Start
that day off with a good breakfast, hopefully fruit and fiber
and if you can, get that 8 hours of sleep. See how much better
it makes you feel. And most of all, what is it we like, it's
laughter in your life. We've got a great show lined up for
you.
We've got an outstanding guest. He is a board certified otorhinolaryngologist.
That's an ENT doctor and we are going to be talking about
hoarseness. Do you get hoarseness every year? If you do, we
are going to learn about what you can do. What are some of
the causes? Why you are getting hoarseness? Could it be dangerous?
Is it a warning sign of cancer? When do you see the doctor?
We will be talking about all of those things. We've got a
lot to learn on this show. Later on we will be talking about
urticaria. What's that? Well, that's simply hives. We will
also be talking about sinusitis. What is some tips on treating
people that have recurrent sinusitis? Is all heartburn due
to GERD or esophageal reflux disease? No and we will be talking
about those other causes and what the treatment is. So, you
will want to stay tuned. We've got a great show and I want
you to learn more about how to stay healthy.
Dr. Bob: We're going to be talking with Clifford Johnson.
I call him Chip Johnson, a long time friend of mine. He is
a board certified ENT. That's an otorhino-laryngologist. That's
the longest name in medicine. We are going to be talking about
hoarseness. Chip, welcome to the Dr. Bob Show.
Dr. Johnson: Thank you for having me.
Dr. Bob: Chip, is there a difference between ENT and
otorhinolaryngologist?
Dr. Johnson: Not at all.
Dr. Bob: What does the ENT doctor basically do?
Dr. Johnson: Well, ENT doctor is a physician that
treats not only the medical illnesses of the ears, nose and
throat but also the surgical ramifications of those same illnesses.
Dr. Bob: And what kind of training does an ENT physician
have?
Dr. Johnson: Normally he will do a year of internship,
a year of general surgery, and then three or four years of
ear, nose and throat specialized training.
Dr. Bob: Did you ever think you would get out of training?
Dr. Johnson: Well, it wasn't too bad when we were
going through it but I am glad that we are through.
Dr. Bob: Let's talk about hoarseness. What causes
hoarseness? Why do people get hoarse?
Dr. Johnson: Very simply, hoarseness is a distortion
of the lining of the vocal cords which disrupts the normal
air flow from the lungs out across the vocal cords and makes
your voice squeaky, makes it harsh, makes it gravely. Depending
on the condition, the type, the resonance of the voice changes.
Dr. Bob: Now, the vocal cords, I think most everybody
knows. Where are they really located?
Dr. Johnson: The vocal cords are in the larynx.
Dr. Bob: Now, the larynx. Where would that be?
Dr. Johnson: That's the voice box and the voice box
is right below the tongue and right above the lungs.
Dr. Bob: And, what if we look at vocal cords. What
do they look like? Is it a string like a violin string or
what is it like?
Dr. Johnson: Vocal cords are white and pearly when
they are in their normal color, when they are not inflamed,
when they are not distorted. They will look like a V and when
the vocal cords are open, when you breath in, the V obviously
is open. When you speak, when you make a voice, the vocal
cords come together. The air coming from the lungs causes
the edge of the vocal cord to vibrate and that's what gives
you your particular voice.
Dr. Bob: What are the common causes of hoarseness?
Dr. Johnson: Many causes of hoarseness. Inflammation
or infection, trauma which can be externally induced or internally
induced by abuse of the voice and, of course, neoplastic with
tumors that can either be benign or malignant.
Dr. Bob: Are there any nerves that are important and
muscles that tighten up the vocal cords?
Dr. Johnson: The main nerve that works the vocal cord
is called a recurrent laryngeal nerve and this nerve is particularly
important when a surgeon does a thyroidectomy or operates
on the thyroid gland because it runs right behind the thyroid
gland and if you are not careful, you can damage that nerve
and leave you with a paralysis of one side of the voice box
which, in turn makes you hoarse.
Dr. Bob: So, the thyroid surgeon really needs to be
careful on that. Let's talk about a vocal cord nodule. What
is a? I've heard of nodules on there. Are they pre-cancerous?
Dr. Johnson: They are not pre-cancerous in most cases.
The rule of thumb is that the term vocal cord nodule is a
totally benign condition. Now, you can see this in adults
or you can see it in children. It is brought on by vocal abuse.
Now, in children they are called screamers nodes because these
kids usually live in big families, they are vying for attention,
and they are abusing their voice. We will ask these parents
in the office, "does this child yell a lot"? "Well,
yes he does. He yells all the time." So, you will see
that in children. In adults you will, they are also called
singer's nodes and preacher's nodes.
Dr. Bob: Preacher's nodes?
Dr. Johnson: Because they tend to get excited in the
pulpit and abuse their voice. Now, a vocal nodule is in very
simple terms, a callous of the vocal cord that occurs between
the anterior one-third and the posterior two-thirds of the
vocal cord. Obviously, if you have a little knot on your vocal
cord, it is going to prevent the vocal cord from coming all
the way together, more air escapes from the lungs and gives
you a hoarser voice.
Dr. Bob: What do you do for it?
Dr. Johnson: In kids you try to get them in speech
therapy because you have to change, not what they are saying
but how they say it. If you can modify a child's speech patterns,
there is a good chance you won't have to do anything to that
nodule. Sometimes the nodules are large enough that you physically
have to remove the nodule and this can be done manually through
a microscope and a laryngoscope which is a device that allows
the physician to look directly at the vocal cords. And in
a lot of cases now, we are using a laser to shave these vocal
nodules off. It's less dramatic to the cord and gives you
a much better result.
Dr. Bob: Is it easy to take a vocal cord nodule out?
Do you have to put the patient under anesthesia? Can you do
it under local? How do you do it?
Dr. Johnson: We most often do it under general anesthesia.
It can be done under local anesthesia but in my experience,
the patient has been much more comfortable if they undergo
general anesthesia and are asleep.
Dr. Bob: Do you ever get any doctor's nodules because
the doctor talks too much?
Dr. Johnson: Well, not very often.
Dr. Bob: Now, in a preacher's nodule, if you tell
somebody vocal cord rest, do these ever go away? I mean, you
just don't talk for three weeks, what happens?
Dr. Johnson: Well, that is the treatment of choice.
We will also treat these folks with steroids, both by mouth
and inhaled. We encourage them to keep their voice box very
moist, drink a lot of fluid and will put them on moisturizing
agents. If they are a smoker, we very strongly encourage them
not to smoke and then voice rest.
Dr. Bob: Is there any pre-cancerous lesion that you
find on the vocal cord? You've mentioned smokers and hoarseness.
I begin to think of, you know, that's one of the things that
causes cancer of the throat. How about leukoplakia? Is that
a pre-cancerous?
Dr. Johnson: Well, obviously cancer of the vocal cords
is a great fear and when a lot of people come see me, that's
what they are primarily interested in.
Dr. Bob: And, Chip, we are going to come back and
we are going to be talking about, "How do you know if
you've got cancer of the vocal cord"? Is there any tips
of the trade that we can find out but first, let's talk to
a patient who had hoarseness and see how they came out.
|
|
|
A Patient's Experience with Hoarseness:
Patient: I first noticed the hoarseness from what
was looked like an allergic reaction to me.
Dr. Bob: How long ago was that?
Patient: Gee, that's been 8 years ago maybe.
Dr. Bob: And how frequent were you getting hoarseness?
Patient: All too frequently. It was, for me, it
was almost like having a head cold the year round.
Dr. Bob: So, you would get hoarse in the morning
and get better as the day goes on or you would have spells
where you lost your voice?
Patient: Very very hoarse in the morning and spells
when I would lose my voice.
Dr. Bob: How long did those spells last?
Patient: Oh, sometimes three or four days.
Dr. Bob: Could you tell that you were getting a
cold from your allergies or getting an infection and that
was what was making you hoarse or was it just drainage?
Patient: Well, it must have been the allergies
simply because there was no way to get the thing well. There
was no medicine that seemed to do any good. I took a lot of
medicines for it.
Dr. Bob: Did you have to clear your throat a lot?
Patient: Oh, constantly.
Dr. Bob: And could you feel the drainage in the
back of your throat?
Patient: I could.
Dr. Bob: And how often would you get a sinus infection
that would get down into your throat and make you hoarse?
Patient: Oh, maybe two to three times a year.
Dr. Bob: And, did the hoarseness keep you from,
or embarrass you when you would talk to people.
Patient: Oh, everytime I answered the phone, they
said, "you must have a terrible cold". Oh no, that's
allergies.
Dr. Bob: Did you get your allergies fixed?
Patient: Yes, I did. I got on a regimen of
Dr. Bob: Some medicines.
Patient: Medicines and allergy shots.
Dr. Bob: And what have they done for you?
Patient: Well, they have made all the difference
in the world.
Dr. Bob: In what respect? How, how's your hoarseness?
Patient: Well, I would say 90% better. I very rarely
get that now.
Dr. Bob: So, instead of four or five times a year
or two to three times a year, you now get them maybe once
a year?
Patient: Exactly and I don't have that head cold
around the year.
Dr. Bob: Yeah, all the time.
Patient: Yes.
Dr. Bob: Instead when you wake up now, hoarseness
would be a rare thing?
Patient: Exactly.
|
|
|
Dr. Bob: Hoarseness can be
a serious thing or it can be a simple thing. We are talking
with Dr. Clifford "Chip" Johnson, of ENT Consultants
of East Tennessee and we have learned about vocal cord nodules.
We've learned about the V of the vocal cords and they vibrate
from air coming from the lungs to make noise. Anything that
interferes with that, causes hoarseness. Now, we were talking
about pre-cancerous or cancer or smoking. Tell me about cancer
of the throat, larynx or vocal cords.
Dr. Johnson: Most often, folks that have a cancer
of the vocal cords, will have a history of smoking at some
time in the past. I have seen folks that stress smoke have
cancer. I have seen folks that stopped smoking ten years ago
that have developed a cancer of the vocal cords. So, the sooner
you quit smoking, the better.
Dr. Bob: That's a key issue. In almost all illnesses
if we could stop smoking, we wouldn't have a lot of problems.
So, if we can stop smoking. What are the symptoms likely to
be?
Dr. Johnson: The main thing that you see is a persistent
hoarseness. If you have a hoarseness or a significant voice
chance over the last two to three weeks, you should see your
family physician, let him evaluate you, and if he feels that
you have a significant hoarseness, he should refer you to
an ear, nose and throat doctor that can evaluate that hoarseness
in the office. Now, there are several ways that we do that.
First of all, I will sit down and I will talk to the patient
about length of the symptoms, the severity of the symptoms,
have they coughed up any blood? Then, I would look at the
vocal cords. Fortunately now, technology has advanced to the
point that we are able to put a little fiberoptic scope through
the nose or mouth and look directly at the vocal cords. The
patient is able to see this on the monitor in the office at
the time
.
Dr. Bob: At the same time you are doing it.
Dr. Johnson: At the same time we do it. We can take photographs
so that when I talk to the patient about the condition, he
can refer to the picture. Now, what we normally see when we
see a cancer of the vocal cord, is a reddish, sometimes whitish
heaped up warty looking ugly thing on the vocal cords.
Dr. Bob: When you look down and see it, you say, "ugh-oh
."
Dr. Johnson: You say, "this is ugly". They
can usually say, "Oou, I see what you are talking about".
Now, what we try to establish at that time is how advanced
is this lesion? Does it involve just the vocal cord? Does
it spread to other parts of the voice box? Because depending
on the extent of the lesion, that will determine the treatment
that we advise. Always we take the patient to surgery and
do a biopsy so that we have a pathologically proven diagnosis.
From there we go into treatment plans which can be as simple
as radiation therapy. Sometimes we combine radiation therapy
with surgery and chemotherapy. If vocal cord cancer is caught
early enough, it is greater than 90% curable.
Dr. Bob: Hey, that's really good to know, that's good
to know. Do you ever see people that come in and they just
had three weeks of hoarseness and they've got vocal cord cancer
that's not 90% treatable?
Dr. Johnson: We do.
Dr. Bob: So, we can
Dr. Johnson: And sometimes there is denial there on
the patient's behalf, ugh, but sometimes the cancer can be
above the vocal cords in the larynx and not really effect
the motion or the air flow through the vocal cords so, they
may have a fairly normal voice with a little more extensive
lesion. These folks will usually have a lot more pain when
they swallow, when they talk than the vocal cord folks will
have.
Dr. Bob: How about if somebody gets hoarseness two
or three times a year? Doctor, I just, twice a year I am getting
hoarse and what can you do to prevent that? What's the common
cause of recurrent hoarseness? Other than screamers, and
..
Dr. Johnson: Well, we have several causes there. One,
the most usual cause is an upper respiratory infection. Now,
this can be associated with allergy. It can be associated
with folks who get recurrent sinusitis with drainage and edema
or swelling of the vocal cords because of that. That's usually
the most common cause. Another cause is reflux or GERD disease.
Dr. Bob: What does the vocal cord look like in a common
cold, upper respiratory infection, sinus infection with drainage?
Dr. Johnson: Instead of the vocal cord being white
and pearly looking, it will be almost gelatinous in appearance.
It will be bubbled up, swollen, just look like ugh, some jello
sitting on the vocal cord. And, of course, that swollen tissue
doesn't conduct air well. So, you get your hoarseness that
way.
Dr. Bob: How about GERD, esophageal reflux disease?
That's where acid comes up and
Dr. Johnson: That's correct. With GERD you will see
more of a redness on the posterior portion of the vocal cord
because this is where the acid hits first. So, you will see
redness and swelling over the aretnoid cartilages which are
the little hinges of the vocal cords that extend anteriorly
on the vocal cords themselves.
Dr. Bob: So, you can look at the throat, look at the
vocal cord with pretty assuredness tell somebody if their
hoarseness is due to reflux disease.
Dr. Johnson: We also like history to go along with it.
Dr. Bob: Heartburn on a full stomach when I have it
Do you refer those patients back to their primary care doctor
or do you tell them to elevate the head of their bed, take
some protein, some ugh
.inhibitors?
Dr. Johnson: Most of the folks have come from their
primary care. I will call the primary care doctor, tell him
what I have found. Some will say, will you treat that? Others
will say, just send them back and I will take care of it.
Then I will follow up with them in a month, six weeks to be
sure that they are getting a reduction in their symptoms.
Dr. Bob: Now, great medicines and I was thinking of
the word, proton pump inhibitor just a minute ago like Nexium
and Prilosec and Prevacid. Those
. Upper respiratory
inf
.. I hear people all the time, "I've got to
give a talk, I'm getting hoarse. What can you do to save me?"
Anything you can do to get somebody's hoarseness to go away
over 24 hours.
Dr. Johnson: Well, my greatest nightmare
(Dr.
Bob laughter) was when I had several friends in the theatre
department at UT and they would be putting on a musical and,
of course, they would practice and rehearse and rehearse and
two days or one day before opening, the star would come in
(Dr. Johnson speaking with a raspy voice) help, help with
a raspy voice (Dr. Johnson speaking with a normal voice) and
there are some things you can do such as big doses of oral
steroids, vaporization, inhaler steroids but the biggest help
is not to talk
.
Dr. Bob: Voice rest
Dr. Johnson: So
..
Dr. Bob: which they don't want to hear.
Dr. Johnson: So, you are in a real bind for a 24-hour
cure. Now, over a few days, you certainly get better but as
we said earlier, voice rest is the key there.
Dr. Bob: Very briefly
somebody with hoarseness,
when do they see the doctor?
Dr. Johnson: After two to three weeks of
.
Dr. Bob: Two to three
.
Dr. Johnson: persistent hoarseness, or let's say hoarseness
is progressively worsening over a week or two period of time.
|
|
|
Supplemental Interview
Dr. Bob: Mark, what is this?
Dr. Mark Overholt:
This is a flexible rhinoscope that allows us to look in people's
nose, ears, and their throats, their vocal cords if they are
hoarse.
Dr. Bob: Now, looking at my vocal cords, that's in
my throat, isn't it?
Dr. Overholt: Yes, right down here.
Dr. Bob: Now, why are you going to look through my
nose to look at my throat? Why don't I just open my mouth?
Dr. Overholt: If you come to see an ear, nose and
throat doctor for hoarseness, you are likely to have this
kind of examination.
Dr. Bob: Is it easier to look at the vocal cords with
this than in the old days when we had a mirror?
Dr. Overholt: The mirror still works great but many
people have a gag reflex and are not able to tolerate the
old time mirror and so the rhinoscope is an alternative better
way for those people.
Dr. Bob: Is this going to hurt me?
Dr. Overholt: Shouldn't hurt a bit. Now, we'll go
around the corner, and this is your voice box.
Dr. Bob: Ugh
Dr. Overholt: Down at the very bottom there are two
white structures that are moving in and out those are the
vocal cords and as you can see, we get an excellent picture
of what the vocal cord does. We can see all around the larynx
or putting the scope in where somebody who may have cancer
and we are going back up and through your nose and you are
all done.
Dr. Bob: Great. How about that? That was painless.
I was expecting a lot of problems and maybe some gagging and
some problems. So, you really, the spray in the back of the
nose and this keeps people from gagging as much and from having
problems.
Dr. Overholt: I can't remember the last time I had
difficulty doing a flexible scope on somebody that I wanted
to look at their vocal cords with the telescope.
Dr. Bob: Is it fun doing a rhinolarygoscopy on your
daddy?
Dr. Overholt: Very fun (laughter).
|
|
|
|
Conclusion of Interviews
Dr. Bob: I want to thank Dr. Chip Johnson for a wonderful
discussion on hoarseness. Bottom line: hoarseness over three
weeks should be evaluated. Progressive, severity of hoarseness
needs to be evaluate. If you've got hoarseness, you need to
get it checked. See your doctor.
And now for those questions from you, the viewing audience.
I've got three really excellent questions we are going to
try and get to on this show.
|
|
|
Letters
Letter #1: Dr. Bob, is heartburn always due to GERD?
First of all, what's GERD?
Response #1: It's gastroesophageal reflux disease.
People eat a meal and they get heartburn after they eat a
meal. They eat, lie down, go to bed, lie down and they get
heartburn then if they have eaten before they lie down. Are
there other types of heartburn? You better bettcha. Well,
the most common cause in the old days used to be a heartburn
due to ulcers. Stomach ulcers or duodenal ulcers and these
now we know 95% of them are most likely due to a bacteria
called helicobactor pylori. To make it shorter, we say H-pylori
bacteria. And you've probably heard about that on the Dr.
Bob Show. This is a bacteria that begins to work on the lining
of the stomach of the duodenum and it causes a gnawing sensation
right in the pit of the stomach or a little bit above the
pit of the stomach. The nice thing about this is that it can
be treated. It's due to a bacteria and we can get antibiotics
for that. It's usually a combination of three different antibiotics
and you have to take them altogether and that's a lot of pills.
And maybe an antibiotic and an antacid and something with
Bismuth in it like Pepto Bismol. That will get rid of the
H-pylori for somebody that is having recurrent ulcers. Important,
if you have chronic ulcer symptoms, it could be involving
the stomach and you need to be sure than an ulcer in the stomach
is not a malignancy. Don't spend too much time treating it
with over-the-counter medications. See your doctor. Have your
doctor evaluate that. It's a serious problem and it can be
treated and you can live happily ever after.
Dr. Bob: Question # 2.
Letter #2: Dr. Bob, as soon as I get over one sinus
infection, I get another one. Are there any tricks of the
trade on getting rid of sinus infections?
Response #2: There are two parts of that question.
# 1. Chronic sinusitis, one infection after the other is frequently
because of a blocked sinus and it never gets really adequately
treated. Sinuses are holes in the head. There's maxillary,
ethmoids, frontal, and in the middle of the head there is
the sphenoid sinuses. And those sinuses can get blocked and
when they get blocked and we treat, we may get 90% better
and get off the antibiotic, it begins to grow and grow and
grow and you start getting headache and yellow or green discolored
nasal exudate and you don't feel good and you feel toxic and
here it comes again and you get another antibiotic. It goes
on and on. An underlying allergy can cause that. An abnormal
nose, your anatomy can do that. But there is one little area
where all the sinuses drain. We call an osteomeatal unit and
that can only be seen with a coronal CT scan of the sinus.
Let me go into those words. That's a coronal CT scan of the
sinus. That will walk right through that drainage area right
there and it will tell the doctor what he can do to try and
get rid of that sinus disease. Sometimes it's a simple surgical
procedure that we go and do what we call endoscopic windows
and we open up the drainage area there. Now, tricks of the
trade for sinus infections, decongestants, saline nasal spray,
an antibiotic three to four weeks if it's chronic recurrent
sinusitis. Acute sinusitis, well, maybe we don't need anything
for that but chronic recurrent usually needs prolonged antibiotics.
The bugs are getting smarter than our antibiotics now and
so frequently we need longer courses. If you've got recurrent
sinusitis, work out a good program with your doctor.
Dr. Bob: And, the last question.
Letter #3: Dr. Bob, I've got hives. I itch all over.
What's the cause of hives and what can I do to get them to
go away?
Response #3: Interesting question. It really bothers
lots and lots of people. Hives is simply histamine that's
released into the skin. It's usually stored in mast cells
and the mast cells what we call degranulate, histamine gets
under the skin and we have itchy welts and it just drives
us crazy when we get that. Good antihistamine - Zyrtec, Allegra,
Claritin excellent antihistamines to help suppress the hives.
What can cause the hives? Food can do it. Chronic infection
can do it. Medications can do it. Hay fever time of the year
can do it and stuff that we are in contact with like soaps,
detergents, fabric softeners, all those things can be causes.
|
|
|
Closing
Dr. Bob: That's all the time that we've got for this
show. I hope you have enjoyed it as much as I have. Remember,
I want you to exercise 15-20 minutes seven days a week. Start
that day off with a breakfast of fruit and fiber. Be sure
you get eight hours sleep and most of all, what do we like,
it's laughter in your life.
If you have a question for Dr. Bob, write to The Dr. Bob
Show - 6700 Baum Drive, Suite 1, Knoxville, TN 37919 or send
your e-mail to letters at letters@drbobshow.com
|
| |
The information
presented by "The Dr. Bob Show"
is intended to supplement your regular health and fitness
care. It should not be a substituted for doctor supervision.
Please consult
a physcian concerning your health care needs.
|
|
RMO Productions
copyright 2002
|
|
|